Best Sugar Free Coffee Syrup In 2023 – Top 9 Recommendations

The best sugar free coffee syrup for me is the Monin Sugar Free Series. Sugar free coffee syrups have been the talk of the town as everyone is beginning to be health conscious. 

On top of that, coffee is one of the most consumed beverages in the world and so naturally, keeping coffee as healthy as possible is essential. If you drink plain-black coffee, kudos to you because it contains zero calories.

However, if you love your coffee sweet, this blog post is specifically for you. Here, I will introduce you to the best sugar-free coffee syrup to allow you to enjoy your sweet coffee beverage guilt free!

Disclosure

Some of the links here are affiliate links, and I may earn if you click on them, AT NO EXTRA cost to you. I hope you find the information here useful! Thanks!

At a glance: Best Sugar Free Coffee Syrup In 2023 (Top 7 Recommendations)

Caffeine Dojo’s Recommended Sugar Free Coffee Syrup

Like you, I have also always enjoyed a sweet treat every once in a while. To reduce the guilt of having these sinful drinks, I’ve opted to switch the sugary syrup to sugar-free alternatives.

Here are the top 7 sugar-free coffee syrups I would recommend. Be it cortado or cappuccinos or americanos, these syrups do a great job in sweetening your coffee!

Miss Mary Sinless Syrup

Being one of the newer brands on the shelf, Miss Mary’s Sinless Syrup has a lot to prove to retain its spot as one of the best sugar-free coffee syrup.

With the goal of providing sugar-free and all-natural (no artificial sweeteners), the home-grown business brand Miss Mary’s Mix kick-off the project as they cannot find any cocktail mixes that fit their healthy lifestyle. 

And best of all, Miss Mary’s Mix sugar-free syrups are keto-friendly, gluten-free, and plant-based. It is safe to say that they have definitely thought about every single one of the customer base.

Miss Mary’s Sinless Syrup uses a blend of organic stevia leaf extract and monk fruit as their natural sweetener. This suppresses the overwhelming taste of stevia that may interfere with the flavors of coffee. However, if you have a sensitive taste bud, the taste of stevia may still be evident.

That said, they offer an extensive amount of different flavors:

• Simple Syrup
• Mocha
• Caramel 
• Madagascar Vanilla 
• Gingerbread Salted Caramel
• Peppermint Mocha 
• Spiced Vanilla

Jordan’s Skinny Mixes

Jordan’s Skinny Mixes coffee syrup is another well-known brand when it comes to the best sugar-free coffee syrup. 

The brand started off with a mission to create the perfect Skinny Margarita. Today, not only have they successfully made Margarita’s guilt-free, they have expanded their syrups offering to other cocktails and coffee beverages. 

Their syrup’s formula involves a mix of stevia, monk fruit, and erythritol. This naturally sweetened syrup goes extremely well with coffee and you will most likely not even miss the real sweeteners!

Also, Jordan’s Skinny Mixes syrups are keto-friendly, gluten-free, and GMO-free allows you to enjoy their products worry-free.

Jordan’s Skinny Mixes offers a huge range of flavors that is too extensive to list here. From basic sugar-free vanilla to sugar-free maple bourbon pecan syrup, they have it all. Feel free to check all of Jordan’s Skinny Mixes syrup offerings! You will be spoilt for choice!

Lakanto Sugar-Free Syrups

Lakanto sugar-free coffee syrup is another popular brand name that finds pride in their sweeteners which are keto-friendly, low-calorie and diabetic friendly. Here, they use a blend of monk fruit extract and erythritol in their products which makes them all natural. 

In terms of taste, the sweet flavor is not too overpowering or artificial which goes very well with coffee. 

While the range of flavors from Lakanto is not extensive, they strive for perfection in terms of the flavors. Their 4 main flavor offerings are Simple Syrup, Vanilla, Hazelnut and Caramel. 

Also, Lakanto sugar-free coffee sweetener range also comes in powdered form! This is excellent for people who travels a lot as it is definitely a hassle to bring liquid sugar-free coffee syrup everywhere.

Monin Sugar-Free Syrups

Monin is no foreign name to baristas and bartenders around the world. Originating from France, Monin boasts premium quality ingredients and natural flavors which allows them to tag their products with premium pricing. 

Naturally sweetened with a blend of erythritol and sucralose, Monin syrups have barely any artificial aftertaste which makes them excellent substitutes for coffee sweeteners. No wonder most cafes opt to use Monin’s sugar-free syrups.

On top of that, Monins’ syrups are quite potent and hence, you do not need to use a lot to achieve the sweetness that you wanted in your coffee. So, for the price you pay, you do actually get a bang for your buck!

Personally, I love their sugar-free caramel. With a pinch of salt and two pumps of Monin’s sugar-free caramel syrup, you will have the perfect base for a salted caramel latte. 

Monin’s range of sugar-free syrups comes in a wide range of flavors and these includes:

• Simple Syrup
• Caramel
• Irish Cream
• Blackberry
• Hazelnut
• Raspberry
• Chocolate
• Almond
• Vanilla
• Triple Sec
• Mango
• French Vanilla
• White Chocolate
• Amaretto

DaVinci Gourmet Sugar-Free Syrups

DaVinci Gourmet is yet another conglomerate brand that is often sighted in cafes and supermarkets. 

Like Monin, the sugar-free syrups from DaVinci Gourmet are also reasonably sweet and do not overpower the natural flavors of the coffee. The sweetener used by DaVinci Gourmet’s sugar syrup is sucralose which is a type of artificial sweetener. 

However, if consumed in moderation, sucralose is proven to cause no harmful effects and has the least aftertaste compared to artificial sweeteners like aspartame.

Being a huge established brand, DaVinci Gourmet boasts a huge variety of sugar-free flavor options. You will only find basic flavors like vanilla, caramel, and hazelnut to fancier flavors like butterscotch caramel, cookie dough and macadamia nut. 

With these flavors, have fun exploring wild flavors with your latte! 

Torani Sugar-Free Syrups

Torani sugar-free syrups is a brand that I am excited to introduce too! 

With more than a 100 years presence in the industry, Torani’s sugar-free syrups flavors are unmatched and the product fan-base certainly loves them. 

The base of Torani sugar-free syrups are crafted with Splenda’s sweetener which is originally formulation of sucralose. However, the company has soon moved on to using natural sweeteners such as Stevia, monk fruit and allulose. 

You will be pleased to know that Torani sugar-free syrup range has over 40 flavors. From classics like vanilla, chocolate, caramel to more exotic ones like chocolate macadamia, toffee nut and not forgetting the all famous Pumpkin Spice.

I am sure there is one flavor that will pique your interest.

ChocZero Sugar-Free Syrup

To all mocha lovers out there, the ChocZero sugar-free syrup is the one for you. ChocZero sugar-free chocolate syrup is no doubt one of the best options to make a sugar-free mocha!

This is mainly because ChocZero sugar-free syrup is able to retain the rich and indulgent flavor. Another added advantage of the ChocZero sugar-free syrup is that it works well with other desserts as well!

It is not all gloomy for non-mocha lovers because fortunately, ChocZero have also expanded their range of sugar-free syrups to caramel and maple too! 

Starting from humble beginnings, you can find ChocZero’s sugar-free syrups at major stores such as Walmart, Sprouts and Whole Foods! So don’t miss out on the hype!

Why Should You Switch To Sugar Free Coffee Syrup?

One of the main reasons to switch to sugar-free coffee syrup is to reduce your overall daily sugar intake and hence reducing the risk of diabetes.

This is because our daily diet alone has a ton of hidden sugars which are usually in the form of carbohydrates and fruits. Not to mention, dessert shops are popping out like mushrooms serving desserts loaded with sugary goodness.

For your information, the Diabetes Research Institute reveals that a whooping 10.5% of the US population has diabetes. And this number does not include undiagnosed cases.

With sugar-free syrups, that is one step towards the right direction to reduce the risk of having diabetes. Plus, your coffee will taste as good anyway!

How To Choose Sugar Free Coffee Syrup?

Walking along the aisles at the supermarket, you will be greeted with a wide selection of sugar-free coffee syrups. So the question is, how do you choose among all the sugar-free coffee syrups?

Flavor

Flavor selection is probably the very first factor you should consider. If you personally love your Iced Vanilla Latte, definitely go for a brand which offers sugar-free vanilla syrup to go with your coffee.

Cost

Cost will be the second most important factor in my opinion. It beats the purpose of being healthy if you have to spend a lot more just to get your coffee to be sugar free. Based on the recommendations above, it’s safe to say that the cost of most sugar-free coffee syrups are now quite affordable. 

That said, the best way to lower the cost of coffee is to get your own roasted coffee beans from your local roaster and brew them yourself. 

Organic Or Non-Organic

As the global community begins to be more health conscious, sugar-free coffee syrup is further divided into organic and non-organic, and artificial and natural. 

Without a doubt, the best combination would be organic and natural sweeteners. However, marketers will certainly charge you a premium by having those words alone on the packaging. 

If your budget allows, why not?

Ease Of Use

The product ease of use is also a factor of consideration when it comes to choosing the best sugar free coffee syrup for yourself. Personally, the product of choice is definitely the one that comes with a pump. This allows you to portion your syrup easily without making a mess.

Fortunately, most of the sugar-free coffee syrups companies do have their products fitted with a pump or they provide a free pump upon purchase!

Packaging

Lastly and probably the least important factor is the packaging. In this context, the packaging is usually either a composite food-safe plastic or glass. With the glass option, it poses more hazard as it will shatter if you accidentally knock it over the counter top. 

Are Sugar Free Coffee Syrup Healthy?

While sugar-free syrup are not exactly the best things in the world as they are often loaded with artificial sweeteners and preservatives.

However, it is a safe option as a sugar substitute if you are watching your daily sugar intake. That said, it is still highly recommended to consume everything in moderation.

In the end, the best way is to curb your cravings for sweet drinks. After all, black coffee when brewed right tastes pretty good! I would recommend exploring specialty coffee which has a ton of unique flavor profiles for you to experience.

How To Make Your Own Sugar-Free Coffee Syrup?

If the list of best sugar free coffee syrup did not interest you, how about home made sugar-free coffee syrup?

Fortunately, it is absolutely easy to make your own sugar-free coffee syrup as all you need are the right ingredients. Here’s a simple home made sugar-free coffee syrup recipe for you.

Author’s Note: Feel free to switch the vanilla extract with any other flavorings that tickle your fancy. Also, you can adjust the mass of the xylitol and monk fruit extract to your desired sweetness.

FAQ On Top Sugar Free Coffee Syrups

What Does Starbucks Use For Sugar Free Syrup?

Starbucks uses “Splenda” when you ask for sugar free syrup. Splenda is derived from sucralose which is a form of artificial sweetener. It works pretty well as a sugar free syrup for coffee as the taste of the sugar free syrup does not overpower the flavor of the coffee.

Does Sugar Free Syrup Raise Blood Sugar?

Sugar free syrup does not raise blood sugar

Artificial sweeteners are many times sweeter than sugar. Because of this, it takes only a small amount of artificial sweeteners to sweeten foods. This is why foods made with artificial sweeteners may have fewer calories than those made with sugar. Sugar substitutes don’t affect your blood sugar level.

What Is The Best Alternative To Sugar In Coffee?

Here are 10 best natural alternative sugar in coffee:

• Honey
• Stevia
• Vanilla Extract
• Coconut Sugar
• Molasses
• Agave Nectar
• Maple Syrup
• Monk Fruit extract
• Agave Nectar
• Palm Sugar

While some of the items in the list above are not exactly sugar free, they are generally better than regular sugar as they are natural.

Closing Notes

That concludes Caffeine Dojo’s best sugar free coffee syrup in 2023. While I do prefer my coffee plain black, I do occasionally love to indulge in sweet coffee treats.

Personally, I love the flavor of hazelnut and chocolate is my go to sugar-free coffee syrup. Absolutely decadent and guilt-free!

Do you have a personal favorite that is not in the list above? Do share it in the comments below with other readers!

If you find this piece of article informational, please do share it with your fellow friends. baristas and home brewers! 

Happy brewing!